Granite vs. Solid Surface

When purchasing countertops it is often difficult to choose between Granite or Solid Surface such as Corian. Let me preface by saying that our shop fabricates and installs both Granite and Solid Surface countertops. Each have their pros and cons. I also should admit that I am pro-granite and as such, my post will most likely come across a little biased.

The main benefit of Solid Surface is that it is seamless. The seams are heated together, and are virtually invisible. Also, the countertops can be re-surfaced as the scratches become prevalent. The main cons of Solid Surface is that it scratches easily, and melts. We have replaced many Solid Surface Countertops that have warped over dishwashers, or under crock pots. We have had better luck with the actual Corian product, rather than a knock off brand.

Granite's main benefit is that it does not scratch or stain, and heat does not affect it. While we recommend using coasters, I have set many hot pans directly on my stone and have never had an ill-effect. I haven't tried it with glass, because I know you must be careful with glass and temperature or it could fracture. The granite stays looking new for much longer than Solid Surface as long as it is taken care of correctly. The main con of Granite is that much of it should be sealed every couple years. However, if Quartz is used, Quartz does not need to be sealed.

Chestnut Zodiaq Quartz desk

If you really like to uniform color and look of Solid Surface, Quartz can offer the same color tones, with all the benefits of granite.

Quartz vs. Granite

A question I often see repeated is what is the difference between quartz and granite?

Let me preface by saying that I do not prefer one over the other, they both are great, it depends on the customers needs.

That being said ... Quartz countertops are comprised primarily of quartz. They are man made and come in a large variety of colors. Quartz has several benefits such as that it does not need to be sealed, and it comes in a very uniform pattern. Both granite and quartz are very hard surfaces, which does not scratch or stain easily.

I have heard from several customers and reps that Quartz does not stain ... We have had quartz stain, but have been able to get the stains out with some hard work and diligence :)

Rain Forest Brown Marble

Chestnut Zodiaq Quartz

My personal opinion on Quartz vs. Granite is to look at the colors and what you want in the home. Granite has natural movements, veining, and variation to the stone, and comes in a wide variety of colors. Quartz, in general, is a very uniform pattern that also comes in many different colors. If you want a look of solid surface, with benefits of granite, Quartz is the product for you! If you want movement, natural stone, and variation, Granite is the product for you!


If price is an issue, Granite has a few basic colors such as Amorello Ornamental, Venetian Gold, and Tan Brown, that are the most economical. Quartz is affordable, but is a little more expensive then these basic granite colors. However, the pricing is generally in-line with the more exotic granite colors.

Fun Job showing Bright Quartz Colors

This stone is One-Quartz Mango and Fresh Linen 

We provide many options in both Granite and Quartz. Our Quartz manufacturers are Caesar Stone, Zodiaz, Cambria, Hanstone, One-Quartz, and Silestone. Granite can be found at our location, and at Contempo Tile and Dal-Tile in St. George. All these vendors are great, and I have not seen a benefit in one over the other.